arduous drive – Booting from a SATA case crashes varied working methods

I really feel considerably obligated to put up a response, since you’ve got referenced by reply. I’m doing so within the type of a solution as an alternative of a sequence of prolonged feedback. 

I’ve learn your authentic deleted query and your present query. Under is what I assume you’ve got achieved.

1. Put in Home windows 10, macOS and/or Linux working methods on the exterior drive. The drive was related to the Mac utilizing a USB-A to SATA cable. I have no idea which macOS or Linux. Nor do I do know if the installations had been achieved individually as a single boot or as some type of multiboot association. The make/mannequin of the USB-A to SATA cable was not specified. I have no idea if the cable was powered. The drive is a 512 GB Samsung, however the mannequin was not given. Data of whether or not drive is a HDD versus SDD and a couple of.5″ versus 3.5″ is omitted.
2. The drive was put in a case with a USB-C port. The make/mannequin of the case was not specified. I have no idea if the case was powered.
3. The case was related to the Mac utilizing both a USB-C to USB-C or USB-C to USB-A cable. I assume the cables are rated for the connection velocity. For USB-C to USB-A this could possibly be as much as 5 Gb/s and for USB-C to USB-C this could possibly be as much as 10 Gb/s. Any out there specs concerning the cables weren’t included within the query.

I’d conclude that the issue was not attributable to the Home windows 10 set up, however relatively from a {hardware} incompatibility. Person Tetsujin posted the next remark to the unique query.

SATA case might change the block measurement marketed to the pc.

The drive makes use of both a 512 byte or 4096 byte sector measurement. If the case stories the flawed sector measurement to the Mac, then one might get a message stating a quantity is not going to mount. One other risk is the case can not accommodate a drive as giant as 512 GB. Or, that you must use a case that’s powered.

Observe: In my posted reply, one can discover the next picture.

This a 500 GB Western Digital exterior HDD. The drive got here in its personal sealed case with a non-detachable USB-A cable. The drive was powered from the USB-A port on the 2018 Mac mini. The switch velocity is as much as 480 Gb/s (USB 2.0).

Further Home windows Set up Steps

You could have lined this difficulty in your gist.

After I posted my reply, the 2018 Mac mini was pretty new. The (U)EFI booting set up used a latest launch of the Home windows Assist Software program for the 2018 Mac mini. Set up issues have been identified to happen when the Home windows Assist Software program for a given Mac has aged. For instance, there may be this query involving a BIOS booting Home windows 11, the place the answer was to enter Audit mode to carry out an early set up of software program updates from each Apple and Microsoft.

References